Colgate Red Raiders vs Villanova Wildcats Predictions September 26, 2026
Villanova will beat Colgate 23-20, with Ja’briel Mace’s versatility and the Wildcats’ late touchdown drive at LIU providing the narrow offensive edge. Colgate’s defense supplies the stronger betting argument: it has allowed no more than 14 points in any of four games. Under 46.5 (-113) is the best bet at the supplied price; the spread is a Pass.
Colgate Red Raiders vs Villanova Wildcats prediction and best bet
The Wildcats get the forecast, but Colgate’s defense makes this a difficult favorite to back. Villanova showed it could rescue a close game when Pat McQuaide directed an eight-play, 85-yard touchdown drive to beat LIU. Mace’s production as both a runner and receiver gives that offense multiple ways to attack.
Under 46.5 (-113) is the strongest wager. Colgate’s four-game scoring defense offers a broader foundation than Villanova’s one dramatic finish: the Raiders rank fifth in the FCS at 11.0 points allowed per game. Pair that with Villanova’s one conversion in eight third-down attempts against LIU, and the case favors fewer successful scoring possessions. Forecast confidence is low.
Odds, game time and how to watch
Date and broadcast: Saturday, September 26, 2026, on ESPN+.
Rankings and record: Villanova is No. 22 and Colgate No. 23 in the AFCA Coaches Poll. Villanova enters at 2-2.
Weather: The September 23 National Weather Service forecast for Villanova, Pennsylvania, called for partly sunny conditions, a high near 68°F and a 30% shower chance Saturday.
SportsJaw odds: Colgate +2.5 (-110), Villanova -2.5 (-110). Moneylines: Colgate +106, Villanova -136. Total: Over 46.5 (-113) or Under 46.5 (-113).