SportsJaw
LeaderboardToday's GamesPredictionsBest BetsConsensus PicksMake Picks
Login / Sign In
Today's GamesLatest PredictionsToday’s Best BetsConsensus PicksTeam PredictionsHead-to-Head MatchupsSJ CoinsAbout SportsJawContact UsLogin / Sign In
HomeMatchupsMake PicksLeaders
SportsJaw

The social platform for sports bettors.

Explore SportsJaw

  • Today’s Picks
  • Latest Predictions
  • Best Bets
  • Leaderboard
  • Make Picks
  • Consensus Picks
  • Team Predictions
  • Head-to-Head

Picks by Sport

  • NFL Picks
  • NCAAF Picks
  • NBA Picks
  • NCAAB Picks
  • MLB Picks
  • NHL Picks

About SportsJaw

  • How It Works
  • SJ Coins
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us

© 2026 SportsJaw. For entertainment purposes only. SportsJaw does not accept or place wagers.

NCAAF MatchupsSat 2:00 PM ET
San Diego Toreros logo
San Diego
Toreros
1-2
versus
ST
St. Thomas - Minnesota
0-0
NCAAF · USD at STMN

Your Picks on San Diego vs STMN

Picks close 15 minutes before game time (ET)
Spread
Moneyline
Total
Expert picks

Top handicapper on this matchup

Selected from available sellers by NCAAF bankroll over the last 30 days. Selections unlock after purchase.

Tip to unlock expert picks

Miamimike

18-7 record · 72% wins
Last 30 days · NCAAF

$500 pick on the spread

San Diego Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota Predictions September 26, 2026

Game time: September 26, 2026 at 2:00 PM ET

Article updated Sep 25, 11:36 AM EDT

By SportsJaw Editorial Team

St. Thomas - Minnesota will beat San Diego, with a projected score of St. Thomas 31, San Diego 28. Home field and the Tommies’ combination of productive passing, rushing and a decisive defensive stand give them the narrow edge. San Diego’s efficient offense makes the upset credible, however, and neither the supplied spread nor total offers a strong enough betting advantage. The official recommendation is Pass.

San Diego Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota prediction and best bet

St. Thomas gets the winning pick in a matchup between teams coming off close victories over Big Sky opponents. The Tommies beat Southern Utah 28-26, while San Diego edged Cal Poly 38-35. Both showed enough offensive production to make a competitive Pioneer Football League opener the most persuasive forecast.

The best betting decision is Pass. San Diego +3.5 (-105) is tempting because a field-goal loss would cover, but its excellent performance against Cal Poly is only one game. St. Thomas also brings a productive quarterback and running back, plus wins in the previous two home meetings with the Toreros. Those competing strengths favor a cautious approach to the price.

Odds, game time and how to watch

Kickoff: Saturday, September 26, 2026, at 1 p.m. CT, according to St. Thomas Athletics.

Venue: O'Shaughnessy Stadium, St. Paul, Minnesota. The 2026 college football matchup is Homecoming for St. Thomas and the PFL opener for both teams.

Record: St. Thomas improved to 3-1 with its September 19 victory.

SportsJaw odds: San Diego +3.5 (-105); St. Thomas -3.5 (-115). Moneyline: San Diego +140; St. Thomas -180. Total: Over 58.5 (-106), Under 58.5 (-120).

San Diego Toreros outlook

San Diego’s September 19 win at Cal Poly offers a substantial offensive argument for taking the road underdog seriously. The Toreros gained 499 yards against Cal Poly’s 384, collected 29 first downs and finished 3-for-3 in the red zone. They also committed no turnovers. That combination suggests the offense had several ways to sustain possessions rather than depending entirely on one scoring play.

Dom Nankil completed 25 of 30 passes for 236 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions. He added 39 rushing yards and another touchdown. Adam Criter supplied the heavier rushing workload, carrying 28 times for 179 yards and finishing with 188 all-purpose yards. Cole Monach caught eight passes for 87 yards and both receiving touchdowns.

Emiliano Salazar then delivered the winning 38-yard field goal with two seconds remaining. The reigning PFL Special Teams Player of the Year gives San Diego another relevant contributor in a projected close finish. The concern is that this clean offensive performance still required a last-second kick to escape with a three-point win. Allowing 35 points leaves room for St. Thomas to answer, even if the Toreros move the ball effectively again.

St. Thomas - Minnesota outlook

St. Thomas has its own evidence of an offense capable of winning a tight game. Nick Peipert threw for 231 yards against Southern Utah on September 19, his second consecutive outing above 200 passing yards. Gabe Abel rushed for 120 yards and a touchdown. Their contributions support a forecast in which the Tommies can produce through both the air and the ground.

The defense supplied the decisive resistance in that 28-26 victory. St. Thomas stopped Southern Utah on fourth down at the Tommies’ 38-yard line and made another fourth-down stop at its own 2-yard line with 1:51 remaining. The latter is a concrete example of preserving a narrow lead under pressure, although it also shows how close Southern Utah came to changing the result.

The Tommies won their previous two home meetings with San Diego, in 2022 and 2024. That history adds modest support to the home pick, rather than guaranteeing another result. St. Thomas was selected third in the preseason PFL poll with 87 points and appeared in the top three on all 10 ballots. San Diego’s first-place selection, with 90 points, suggests these were closely regarded contenders entering the season.

Key matchup factors

The central question is whether San Diego can repeat its mistake-free execution against a different defense. Another efficient afternoon would put pressure on St. Thomas to finish drives, while a turnover or stalled red-zone possession could give the home favorite the separation it needs. Those are matchup possibilities, not established turnover or defensive trends.

SportsJaw’s September 23 consensus snapshot lists San Diego +3.5 (-105) as the community leader at 67%. Qualified handicapper picks also favor that selection at 67%. Those are separate groups, not sportsbook betting shares or a 67% chance of covering. Their agreement adds context to the underdog case, but the football evidence still leaves a narrow and uncertain margin.

San Diego Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota spread prediction

Spread recommendation: Pass on San Diego +3.5 (-105) and St. Thomas -3.5 (-115). The projected three-point home win falls inside San Diego’s spread, making the Toreros the more appealing side at first glance.

The reservation is the precision that wager demands. One additional scoring opportunity could turn a narrow St. Thomas victory into a cover, and both teams just demonstrated productive passing and rushing. San Diego’s strong recent offense argues against confidently laying the points. St. Thomas’ home results and offensive balance keep the underdog from becoming an official bet.

San Diego Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota total prediction

Total recommendation: Pass on Over 58.5 (-106) and Under 58.5 (-120). The projected 59 points sit only half a point above the line, too small a difference to carry an Over recommendation by itself.

San Diego’s previous game produced 73 combined points, while St. Thomas’ produced 54. Those contrasting results illustrate the uncertainty around this number. The Toreros’ efficient offense offers an Over argument; the Tommies’ goal-line stand illustrates how a scoring chance can disappear. SportsJaw’s total snapshot lists Over at 50%, which adds no majority preference to the scoring assessment.

San Diego Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota projected score

Game forecast: St. Thomas - Minnesota 31, San Diego 28. The Tommies get the nod for their home setting, recent offensive balance and demonstrated ability to protect a narrow lead with a crucial defensive stop.

San Diego presents the strongest counterargument through Nankil’s accuracy and Criter’s rushing production. The Toreros also won the latest series meeting 30-27 on September 27, 2025, despite St. Thomas holding a 3-2 series lead. An upset would fit the competitive picture.

Confidence is low. The winning forecast favors St. Thomas, but neither that choice nor a projected 59-point total creates a compelling wager at these prices. The single official SportsJaw betting recommendation is Pass.

SportsJawGame Predictions
Predicted score

USD28

STMN31

Projected winner St. Thomas - MinnesotaConfidenceSlight Lean — San Diego Toreros
Pick on the Spread

Slight Lean — San Diego Toreros +3.5

Editorial pick at publication: Pass on San Diego Toreros +3.5 (-105) and St. Thomas - Minnesota -3.5 (-115)

Pick on the Total

Slight Lean — Over 58.5

Editorial pick at publication: Pass on Over 58.5 (-106) and Under 58.5 (-120)

Sources

  • Pioneer Football LeagueThe Pioneer Football League Report: Week Four
  • University of San Diego AthleticsPrevious-game context: Salazar's Last-Second Field Goal Lifts USD Past Cal Poly, 38-35
  • University of St. Thomas AthleticsPrevious-game context: Tommies stun (RV) Southern Utah 28-26

SportsJaw Toreros vs St. Thomas - Minnesota game preview analysis and predictions incorporate current odds, injury reports, team statistics and market data. Information is updated regularly, but lines and player availability can change. Please confirm current information before wagering. how our predictions work.

Keep browsing

More NCAAF matchups

Compare predictions, consensus picks and recorded odds for other NCAAF games on this slate.

View all NCAAF games
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
TEXAS-4.5 (-115)
TENN+4.5 (-105)
O/U54.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
ILLINO+27 (-108)
OHIOST-27 (-110)
O/U53.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
WAKE+13.5 (-108)
LOUISV-13.5 (-110)
O/U57.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
SDST+3 (-115)
TOLEDO-3 (-105)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
BALLST+3 (-108)
KENT-3 (-110)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
COLO+9.5 (-108)
BAYLOR-9.5 (-110)
O/U55.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
UNLV-13.5 (-110)
AKRON+13.5 (-110)
O/U52.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
VTECH-14 (-110)
BOST.C+14 (-110)
O/U47.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
CSU+14 (-110)
UTSA-14 (-110)
O/U56.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
NH+3.5 (-105)
shu-3.5 (-115)
O/U45.5
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
PRPRE+7.5 (-110)
mrst-7.5 (-110)
O/U46.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 12:00 PM
SAMHOU+34.5 (-110)
TXTECH-34.5 (-110)
O/U56
NCAAFSat 12:30 PM
clmb-6.5 (-110)
gtwn+6.5 (-110)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 12:30 PM
hc+4.5 (-111)
UL.LAF-4.5 (-115)
O/U49.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 12:45 PM
S.ALA+20.5 (-110)
KENTUC-20.5 (-110)
O/U54.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
LILIN+26.5 (-109)
E.MICH-26.5 (-113)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
NDKOTA-17.5 (-110)
IND.ST+17.5 (-110)
O/U58.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
yale-14.5 (-105)
cor+14.5 (-115)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
STNYBK-10.5 (-115)
FORDHM+10.5 (-105)
O/U55.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
LEH-10.5 (-118)
PENN+10.5 (-108)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
DU-13.5 (-105)
dav+13.5 (-115)
O/U53.5
NCAAFSat 1:00 PM
NENH+8.5 (-110)
MEmer-8.5 (-110)
O/U46.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 1:30 PM
UCLA-1.5 (-110)
MARYL+1.5 (-110)
O/U56.5
NCAAFSat 1:30 PM
TNTECH-14.5 (-113)
WOFFOR+14.5 (-113)
O/U46.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
SDKOT+1.5 (-115)
YOUNG-1.5 (-105)
O/U64.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
NOTRD-28 (-104)
PURDUE+28 (-110)
O/U58
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
NIU+10.5 (-110)
GAST-10.5 (-108)
O/U56.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
FURMAN+3.5 (-120)
RICHMO-3.5 (-106)
O/U44.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
UTM+16.5 (-110)
AUST-16.5 (-110)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
MAINE+5.5 (-102)
ELON-5.5 (-125)
O/U45.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
but-8.5 (-106)
valp+8.5 (-120)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 2:00 PM
chat-10.5 (-110)
CITADL+10.5 (-110)
O/U46.5
NCAAFSat 2:30 PM
COLGATE+2.5 (-110)
VILLAN-2.5 (-110)
O/U46.5
NCAAFSat 3:00 PM
HAW-2.5 (-110)
WYO+2.5 (-110)
O/U43.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
OKLA+13.5 (-108)
GEORGI-13.5 (-110)
O/U44.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
BOISE-7 (-115)
W.MICH+7 (-105)
O/U49.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
O-MISS+3.5 (-115)
FLA-3.5 (-105)
O/U59
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
IOWA+5.5 (-110)
MICH-5.5 (-110)
O/U38.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
UTAH-8 (-108)
IOWAST+8 (-110)
O/U47.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
NEWMEX-11.5 (-110)
NMEXST+11.5 (-110)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
UCONN+3.5 (-110)
MIOH-3.5 (-110)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
TCU-3 (-109)
UCF+3 (-105)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
webb+23.5 (-110)
MARSHL-23.5 (-110)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
rmu+28.5 (-115)
BUFF-28.5 (-115)
O/U45.5
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
W.CAR+1.5 (-111)
etsu-1.5 (-115)
O/U62.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 3:30 PM
VMI+19.5 (-110)
SAMFOR-19.5 (-110)
O/U49.5
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
HOUSTO-17.5 (-115)
GASOU+17.5 (-105)
O/U56.5
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
NONCCU+35.5 (-102)
E.CAR-35.5 (-118)
O/U56.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
RHODEI-25.5 (-105)
NONCAT+25.5 (-115)
O/U52.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
LAMAR-9.5 (-110)
NICHOLL+9.5 (-110)
O/U45.5
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
txso+2.5 (-110)
ALCORN-2.5 (-110)
O/U57.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 4:00 PM
W.ILL+8.5 (-115)
NOuna-8.5 (-105)
O/U53.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 4:15 PM
VANDY+9.5 (-108)
AUBRN-9.5 (-110)
O/U55.5
NCAAFSat 5:00 PM
NEBR-5.5 (-115)
MICHST+5.5 (-105)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 5:00 PM
WISCSN+10 (-110)
PENNST-10 (-110)
O/U44.5
NCAAFSat 5:00 PM
USF-17.5 (-110)
BGREEN+17.5 (-108)
O/U49
NCAAFSat 5:00 PM
ILL.ST-20.5 (-110)
N.IOWA+20.5 (-110)
O/U59.5
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
JMSMAD-6 (-110)
OLDDOM+6 (-110)
O/U44.5
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
DELEWAR+19.5 (-108)
VIRGNA-19.5 (-110)
O/U52.5
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
IW+30.5 (-105)
TXST-30.5 (-115)
O/U64.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
LOLIU+35.5 (-115)
FIU-35.5 (-115)
O/U52.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
TOWSN+3.5 (-130)
DELAST-3.5 (+105)
O/U50.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 6:00 PM
CAMBP-18.5 (-113)
hamp+18.5 (-113)
O/U57.5
NCAAFSat 6:30 PM
ULL-10 (-110)
CHARLT+10 (-108)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
OKLAST+2 (-110)
WESTV-2 (-110)
O/U61
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
S.CARO+12.5 (-110)
ALAB-12.5 (-110)
O/U54
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
KAN.ST-6.5 (-105)
CINCIN+6.5 (-115)
O/U55.5
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
S.MISS+17.5 (-110)
TULANE-17.5 (-110)
O/U52.5
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
MIDTEN+7 (-105)
JACKST-7 (-112)
O/U51.5
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
kenn+6.5 (-110)
AKST-6.5 (-110)
O/U52.5
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
CALPOL+2.5 (-105)
E.WASH-2.5 (-115)
O/U59.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
ALAAMU-1.5 (-110)
famu+1.5 (-110)
O/U48.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
WEWFLA+6.5 (-122)
SOSEMO-6.5 (-104)
O/U52.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
sou+20.5 (-105)
JACKST-20.5 (-115)
O/U57.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
TETXA+4.5 (-110)
MCNESE-4.5 (-110)
O/U51.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
PV-10.5 (-111)
gram+10.5 (-115)
O/U54.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
SOSCST-14.5 (-105)
cook+14.5 (-115)
O/U58.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:00 PM
S.ILL-18.5 (-105)
MURRAY+18.5 (-115)
O/U53.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:30 PM
OREG-3 (-108)
USC+3 (-106)
O/U61.5
NCAAFSat 7:30 PM
TXAM+9.5 (-108)
LSU-9.5 (-110)
O/U52
NCAAFSat 7:30 PM
TROY+3 (-110)
UTST-3 (-108)
O/U47
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 7:30 PM
ARIZON-10.5 (-110)
WSHST+10.5 (-110)
O/U48
NCAAFSat 7:30 PM
APP-ST+14 (-110)
NCST-14 (-110)
O/U55
NCAAFSat 7:45 PM
MIZZOU+6 (-110)
MIS.ST-6 (-110)
O/U58.5
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
TULSA+7 (-105)
ARK-7 (-112)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
FLAATL-11.5 (-110)
UL.MON+11.5 (-110)
O/U58
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
UTUTU+7.5 (-115)
unco-7.5 (-105)
O/U49.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
ID.ST-10.5 (-115)
SUTAH+10.5 (-105)
O/U60.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
PORTST+9.5 (-110)
WEBER-9.5 (-110)
O/U65.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 8:00 PM
MERCR+3.5 (-110)
ACU-3.5 (-110)
O/U48.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 9:00 PM
MASS-4.5 (-110)
sac+4.5 (-110)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 9:00 PM
OREGST-10.5 (-115)
UTEP+10.5 (-105)
O/U56
NCAAFSat 9:00 PM
MIZ.ST+34.5 (-110)
SMU-34.5 (-110)
O/U59.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 10:00 PM
RICE+13.5 (-110)
FRESNO-13.5 (-110)
O/U44.5
NCAAFSat 10:00 PM
MONTAN+3.5 (-130)
CALDAV-3.5 (+105)
O/U61.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 10:30 PM
GATECH-3.5 (-105)
STANFO+3.5 (-115)
O/U48.5
NCAAFSat 10:30 PM
AIRFOR-5.5 (-110)
NEVADA+5.5 (-110)
O/U50.5
NCAAFSat 10:30 PM
N.ARIZ+19.5 (-106)
mtst-19.5 (-120)
O/U56.5
Matchup Coming Soon
NCAAFSat 11:00 PM
MINN+10 (-110)
WASH-10 (-110)
O/U46