Phillies vs. Mets: Competing pitching signals favor a pass
The Mets are -140 and the Phillies +120, but the pitching evidence does not establish a clear betting edge at Citi Field.
Matchup and starting pitchers
Philadelphia visits New York at Citi Field on September 17, 2026, for a 7:15 p.m. ET MLB matchup. MLB.com lists right-handers Aaron Nola and Nolan McLean as the probable starters for the Phillies and Mets, respectively.
McLean has the stronger season ERA: 3.24 compared with Nola’s 4.69. He also has 184 strikeouts to Nola’s 165, although those totals alone do not establish a strikeout-rate advantage.
Recent starts complicate the season comparison
Covers lists Nola with a 2.01 ERA across his five most recent starts, averaging 4.6 hits, 1.8 walks and 5.4 strikeouts. On September 11 at Atlanta, he allowed two runs, both earned, in 6 1/3 innings. Both runs came with two home runs allowed, a caution alongside his otherwise effective outing.
McLean’s last five starts carry a 2.40 ERA, with averages of 5.0 hits, 3.2 walks and 5.0 strikeouts. His September 11 appearance against the Yankees was less encouraging: 10 hits and five earned runs in five innings.
There is counterevidence to dismissing McLean after that start. On July 19 against Philadelphia, he delivered six scoreless innings with two hits, two walks and 10 strikeouts. That outing supports his ability to handle this opponent, but one meeting cannot settle the rematch.
Betting decision
Philadelphia owns an 84-68 record compared with New York’s 69-83, while their last-10 records are 4-6 and 5-5. Those results add context without establishing value on either moneyline.

