New York Islanders versus Toronto Maple Leafs Head-to-head history

Scores, recaps and recorded betting results from the five most recent meetings in SportsJaw history. Toronto Maple Leafs won the most recent meeting against the New York Islanders. The latest result was the Toronto Maple Leafs' one-point 2-1 win on September 30, 2026.

SportsJaw’s stored game records date back to 2015. The news feed shows up to the five most recent completed meetings.

Head-to-head history

Last five meetings

Recent game recaps, recorded odds and betting results

Sept 30, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	1	+122 L	+1.5 (-220) W	O 6 (-108) L U 6 (-112) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	2	-142 W	-1.5 (+180) L	O 6 (-108) L U 6 (-112) W

Toronto Maple Leafs defeated New York Islanders 2-1

Toronto Maple Leafs defeated New York Islanders 2-1 on September 30, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. Toronto Maple Leafs' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded New York Islanders +1.5 (-220) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 3 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.

Team	1	2	3	T
NYI	0	0	1	1
TOR	2	0	0	2

Mar 17, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	3	-155 W	-1.5 (+167) W	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	1	+136 L	+1.5 (-193) L	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 on March 17, 2026, a 2-goal decision in the series. New York Islanders' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded New York Islanders -1.5 (+167) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 4 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.

Team	1	2	3	T
NYI	2	1	0	3
TOR	0	1	0	1

Jan 3, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	3	-115 L	-1.5 (+219) L	O 5.5 (-110) W U 5.5 (-110) L
New York IslandersNYI	4	-105 W	+1.5 (-265) W	O 5.5 (-110) W U 5.5 (-110) L

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3

Team	1	2	3	4	T
TOR	0	2	1	0	3
NYI	0	1	2	1	4

Jan 2, 2025	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	2	-108 W	-1.5 (+220) L	O 5.5 (-110) L U 5.5 (-110) W
New York IslandersNYI	1	-110 L	+1.5 (-260) W	O 5.5 (-110) L U 5.5 (-110) W

Dec 31, 2024	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	1	+112 L	+1.5 (-220) L	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	3	-132 W	-1.5 (+180) W	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W

Verified performance

Experts who know these teams

Weighted grade based on 75% profit from head-to-head bets and 25% from profits earned betting on either team.

BrycetWeighted grade61+$1,979 · 5 picks3–2 W–L · 60.0%2

VfernandezWeighted grade51+$1,754 · 4 picks4–0 W–L · 100.0%3

Hustle$Weighted grade51+$1,489 · 4 picks4–0 W–L · 100.0%

RankHandicapperGradeProfit

4Georgew3–1 W–L · 75.0%46+$920 5Coolio8–4 W–L · 66.7%46+$254 6Swamipicks3–0 W–L · 100.0%44+$1,378 711884602074–4 W–L · 50.0%44+$73 8Ironcladlocks2–1 W–L · 66.7%42+$950 9Tgodfrey3–0 W–L · 100.0%41+$1,343 10Mickeyt2–2 W–L · 50.0%41+$659 11Miamimike2–1 W–L · 66.7%40+$974 12Jtgarcia2–1 W–L · 66.7%40+$780 13Mickey6191–3 W–L · 25.0%39+$370 14Mookiebets2–0 W–L · 100.0%38+$1,905 15Fisher493–1 W–L · 75.0%38+$1,031 16Mrshiny3–2 W–L · 60.0%38+$184 17PremierPicks2–0 W–L · 100.0%36+$1,606 18Altuve273–2 W–L · 60.0%35+$20 19DerekFisher2–0 W–L · 100.0%34+$849 20Roderick8061–1 W–L · 50.0%31+$826

Expert grades weight verified head-to-head profit at 75% and profit on other games involving either team at 25%, with a confidence adjustment until ten qualifying picks are recorded.