New York Islanders versus Toronto Maple Leafs Head-to-head history

SportsJaw’s stored game records date back to 2015. The news feed shows up to the five most recent completed meetings.

Head-to-head history

Last five meetings

Recent game recaps, recorded odds and betting results

Oct 17, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	4	+110 W	+1.5 (-225) W	O 6 (-121) L U 6 (+101) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	1	-130 L	-1.5 (+189) L

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 on October 17, 2026, a 3-goal decision in the series. New York Islanders' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 1-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded New York Islanders +1.5 (-225) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 5 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.

Team	1	2	3	T
New York Islanders	1	1	2	4
Toronto Maple Leafs	0	0	1	1

Sept 30, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	1	+122 L	+1.5 (-220) W	O 6 (-108) L U 6 (-112) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	2	-142 W	-1.5 (+180) L

Toronto Maple Leafs defeated New York Islanders 2-1

Toronto Maple Leafs defeated New York Islanders 2-1 on September 30, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. Toronto Maple Leafs' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded New York Islanders +1.5 (-220) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 3 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.

Team	1	2	3	T
New York Islanders	0	0	1	1
Toronto Maple Leafs	2	0	0	2

Mar 17, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	3	-155 W	-1.5 (+167) W	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	1	+136 L	+1.5 (-193) L

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1

New York Islanders defeated Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 on March 17, 2026, a 2-goal decision in the series. New York Islanders' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded New York Islanders -1.5 (+167) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 4 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.

Team	1	2	3	T
New York Islanders	2	1	0	3
Toronto Maple Leafs	0	1	0	1

Jan 3, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	3	-115 L	-1.5 (+219) L	O 5.5 (-110) W U 5.5 (-110) L
New York IslandersNYI	4	-105 W	+1.5 (-265) W

Jan 2, 2025	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Toronto Maple LeafsTOR	2	-108 W	-1.5 (+220) L	O 5.5 (-110) L U 5.5 (-110) W
New York IslandersNYI	1	-110 L	+1.5 (-260) W

Verified performance

Experts who know these teams

Weighted grade based on 75% profit from head-to-head bets and 25% from profits earned betting on either team.

1BrycetWeighted grade61+$1,979 · 5 picks3–2 W–L · 60.0%2VfernandezWeighted grade51+$1,754 · 4 picks4–0 W–L · 100.0%3Hustle$Weighted grade51+$1,489 · 4 picks4–0 W–L · 100.0%

RankHandicapperGradeProfit

4Mookiebets3–0 W–L · 100.0%46+$2,0205Georgew3–1 W–L · 75.0%46+$9206Coolio8–4 W–L · 66.7%46+$2547Swamipicks3–0 W–L · 100.0%44+$1,378811884602074–4 W–L · 50.0%44+$739Ironcladlocks2–1 W–L · 66.7%42+$95010Mickeyt2–2 W–L · 50.0%41+$65911Tgodfrey3–0 W–L · 100.0%40+$1,34312Miamimike2–1 W–L · 66.7%40+$97413Jtgarcia2–1 W–L · 66.7%40+$78014Mickey6191–3 W–L · 25.0%40+$37015Fisher493–1 W–L · 75.0%38+$1,03116Mrshiny3–2 W–L · 60.0%38+$18417PremierPicks2–0 W–L · 100.0%36+$1,60618Altuve273–2 W–L · 60.0%36+$2019DerekFisher2–0 W–L · 100.0%34+$84920Mrpink2–0 W–L · 100.0%31+$1,620

Expert grades weight verified head-to-head profit at 75% and profit on other games involving either team at 25%, with a confidence adjustment until ten qualifying picks are recorded.