Columbus Blue Jackets versus Pittsburgh Penguins Head-to-head history

Scores, recaps and recorded betting results from the five most recent meetings in SportsJaw history. Columbus Blue Jackets have won the last 2 meetings against the Pittsburgh Penguins. The latest result was the Columbus Blue Jackets' one-point 3-2 win on October 9, 2026.

SportsJaw’s stored game records date back to 2015. The news feed shows up to the five most recent completed meetings.

Head-to-head history

Last five meetings

Recent game recaps, recorded odds and betting results

Oct 9, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	2	-103 L	+1.5 (-251) W	O 6.5 (-125) L U 6.5 (+109) W
Columbus Blue JacketsCLM	3	-111 W	-1.5 (+215) L	O 6.5 (-125) L U 6.5 (+109) W

Columbus Blue Jackets defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 3-2

Columbus Blue Jackets defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 3-2 on October 9, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. Columbus Blue Jackets' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 1-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded Pittsburgh Penguins +1.5 (-251) spread, Pittsburgh Penguins covered, while the 5 combined goals finished under the recorded total of 6.5.

Team	1	2	3	4	5	T
Pittsburgh Penguins	0	1	1	0	0	2
Columbus Blue Jackets	1	1	0	0	1	3

Jan 17, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Columbus Blue JacketsCLM	4	+100 W	+1.5 (-230) W	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	3	-117 L	-1.5 (+190) L	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L

Columbus Blue Jackets defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 4-3

Columbus Blue Jackets defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 4-3 on January 17, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. Columbus Blue Jackets' strongest period was the 2nd period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 (-230) spread, Columbus Blue Jackets covered, while the 7 combined goals finished over the recorded total of 6.5.

Team	1	2	3	4	5	T
Columbus Blue Jackets	1	2	0	0	1	4
Pittsburgh Penguins	2	0	1	0	0	3

Jan 4, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	5	+113 W	+1.5 (-220) W	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L
Columbus Blue JacketsCLM	4	-130 L	-1.5 (+180) L	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L

Pittsburgh Penguins defeated Columbus Blue Jackets 5-4

Pittsburgh Penguins defeated Columbus Blue Jackets 5-4 on January 4, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. Pittsburgh Penguins' strongest period was the 3rd period, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded Pittsburgh Penguins +1.5 (-220) spread, Pittsburgh Penguins covered, while the 9 combined goals finished over the recorded total of 6.5.

Team	1	2	3	4	T
Pittsburgh Penguins	1	1	2	1	5
Columbus Blue Jackets	3	1	0	0	4

Nov 28, 2025	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	4	+115 W	+1.5 (-218) W	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L
Columbus Blue JacketsCLM	3	-135 L	-1.5 (+180) L	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L

Jan 7, 2025	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Columbus Blue JacketsCLM	4	+125 W	+1.5 (-190) W	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	3	-145 L	-1.5 (+164) L	O 6.5 (-110) W U 6.5 (-110) L

Verified performance

Experts who know these teams

Weighted grade based on 75% profit from head-to-head bets and 25% from profits earned betting on either team.

CoolioWeighted grade75+$651 · 16 picks13–3 W–L · 81.3%2

OddssharkWeighted grade73+$750 · 20 picks16–4 W–L · 80.0%3

1188460207Weighted grade61+$1,606 · 5 picks3–2 W–L · 60.0%

RankHandicapperGradeProfit

4DerekFisher2–0 W–L · 100.0%46+$909 5Brycet3–1 W–L · 75.0%42+$241 6Muterovince4–0 W–L · 100.0%39+$450 7Bjenkins2–1 W–L · 66.7%38+$147 8Tgodfrey2–0 W–L · 100.0%36+$992 9Jtgarcia1–1 W–L · 50.0%36+$600 10Covers6–2 W–L · 75.0%34+$15 11Mtgoldstein2–0 W–L · 100.0%33+$401 12Jaredkuntz1–1 W–L · 50.0%32+$127 13Drpaul2–0 W–L · 100.0%31+$492 14Georgew1–0 W–L · 100.0%30+$560 15Sammy521–1 W–L · 50.0%30+$205 16Roderick8061–0 W–L · 100.0%28+$455 17Altuve272–0 W–L · 100.0%27+$97 18Teddy7181–0 W–L · 100.0%25+$284 19Aliencreation2–1 W–L · 66.7%25-$18 20Shoulderfat1–0 W–L · 100.0%24+$455

Expert grades weight verified head-to-head profit at 75% and profit on other games involving either team at 25%, with a confidence adjustment until ten qualifying picks are recorded.