New York Islanders versus Pittsburgh Penguins Head-to-head history

Scores, recaps and recorded betting results from the five most recent meetings in SportsJaw history.

SportsJaw’s stored game records date back to 2015. The news feed shows up to the five most recent completed meetings.

Head-to-head history

Last five meetings

Recent game recaps, recorded odds and betting results

Feb 3, 2026	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	4	-120 L	-1.5 (+220) L	O 5.5 (-110) W U 5.5 (-110) L
New York IslandersNYI	5	+100 W	+1.5 (-270) W	O 5.5 (-110) W U 5.5 (-110) L

New York Islanders defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 5-4

New York Islanders defeated Pittsburgh Penguins 5-4 on February 3, 2026, a 1-goal decision in the series. New York Islanders' strongest period was the 1st period, when it outscored its opponent 2-1. Against SportsJaw's recorded Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 (+220) spread, New York Islanders covered, while the 9 combined goals finished over the recorded total of 5.5.

Team	1	2	3	4	T
PIT	1	2	1	0	4
NYI	2	0	2	1	5

Oct 9, 2025	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	3	-125 L	-1.5 (+205) L	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	4	+105 W	+1.5 (-245) W	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L

Pittsburgh Penguins defeated New York Islanders 4-3

Team	1	2	3	T
NYI	1	2	0	3
PIT	1	2	1	4

Dec 29, 2024	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
New York IslandersNYI	2	-130 L	-1.5 (+194) L	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	3	+112 W	+1.5 (-230) W	O 6 (-110) L U 6 (-110) W

Pittsburgh Penguins defeated New York Islanders 3-2

Team	1	2	3	T
NYI	0	0	2	2
PIT	1	1	1	3

Dec 28, 2024	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	3	+139 L	+1.5 (-180) L	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L
New York IslandersNYI	6	-160 W	-1.5 (+155) W	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L

Nov 5, 2024	Score	Moneyline	Puck line	Game total
Pittsburgh PenguinsPIT	3	+117 L	+1.5 (-205) W	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L
New York IslandersNYI	4	-135 W	-1.5 (+178) L	O 6 (-110) W U 6 (-110) L

Verified performance

Experts who know these teams

Weighted grade based on 75% profit from head-to-head bets and 25% from profits earned betting on either team.

OddssharkWeighted grade67+$485 · 43 picks24–18 W–L · 57.1%2

CoolioWeighted grade66+$311 · 20 picks12–8 W–L · 60.0%3

CoversWeighted grade57+$172 · 20 picks11–9 W–L · 55.0%

RankHandicapperGradeProfit

4RURushmo164–0 W–L · 100.0%51+$649 5Geauxtigers2–2 W–L · 50.0%49+$610 6Jtpham2–0 W–L · 100.0%38+$2,065 7Dtownsend2–0 W–L · 100.0%38+$1,326 8Dawhiz2–1 W–L · 66.7%37+$258 9Mrshiny5–4 W–L · 55.6%36-$405 10Nutinbutlocks3–0 W–L · 100.0%35+$725 11Rcollins2–2 W–L · 50.0%35+$324 12NINico3–0 W–L · 100.0%34+$622 13Swamipicks1–0 W–L · 100.0%31+$909 14Mickeyt1–0 W–L · 100.0%31+$855 15Perjjj2–1 W–L · 66.7%31+$250 1611884602071–0 W–L · 100.0%30+$1,100 17Phillyk2–1 W–L · 66.7%30+$375 18Mickey6192–1 W–L · 66.7%30+$51 19Tjwins1–0 W–L · 100.0%29+$455 20Hustle$1–0 W–L · 100.0%29+$403

Expert grades weight verified head-to-head profit at 75% and profit on other games involving either team at 25%, with a confidence adjustment until ten qualifying picks are recorded.