SportsJaw
LeaderboardToday's GamesBest BetsOdds ComparisonConsensus PicksMake Picks
Login / Sign In
Today's GamesLatest PredictionsToday’s Best BetsOdds ComparisonConsensus PicksTeam PredictionsHead-to-Head MatchupsSJ CoinsAbout SportsJawContact UsLogin / Sign In
HomeMatchupsMake PicksLeaders
SportsJaw

The social platform for sports bettors.

Explore SportsJaw

  • Today’s Picks
  • Predictions
  • Best Bets
  • Leaderboard
  • Make Picks
  • Odds Comparison
  • Consensus Picks
  • Team Predictions
  • Head-to-Head
  • Game Briefing

Picks by Sport

  • NFL Picks
  • NCAAF Picks
  • NBA Picks
  • NCAAB Picks
  • MLB Picks
  • NHL Picks

About SportsJaw

  • How It Works
  • SJ Coins
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us

21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Picks are opinions, not guarantees. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

© 2026 SportsJaw. For entertainment purposes only. SportsJaw does not accept or place wagers.

  1. Home
  2. MLB Picks
  3. Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees
Wed 7:05 PM ET
Toronto Blue Jays logo
Toronto
Blue Jays6
K. Gausman RHP
versus
New York Yankees logo
New York
Yankees1
M. King RHP
Final
Team123456789T
Toronto Blue Jays0010000236
New York Yankees00000000

Toronto Blue Jays Look to Extend Lead Over Yankees in Tuesday Night Showdown

Game time: September 20, 2023 at 7:05 PM ET

Venue: Yankee Stadium — Bronx, New York

Article updated Sep 19, 6:23 PM EDT

Published by SportsJaw Editorial Team

The two teams face off Tuesday night for the first of six remaining head to head matchups. Toronto Blue Jays (83-67) and New York Yankees (76-74) will play on Tuesday at 7:05

Game outlook

The two teams face off Tuesday night for the first of six remaining head to head matchups. Toronto Blue Jays (83-67) and New York Yankees (76-74) will play on Tuesday at 7:05 PM EDT at Yankee Stadium for the first matchup. Kevin Gausman vs Michael King, with the Blue Jays being the betting favorites, with the line has not changing. The second clash of the three-game set will decide who gets closer to their final fate.

Game Info

When: Wednesday, 9/20/2023 @ 7:05pm EST

Where: Yankee Stadium Stadium Blue Jays vs Yankees Betting Odds Moneyline: Blue Jays -116 | Yankees +106

Spread: Blue Jays -1.5 (+150) | Yankees +1.5 (-180)

Total: Over/Under 7.5 (-110)

Based on the moneyline, the implied probability that Toronto will win straight-up is 54%.

Toronto Blue Jays

Holding a 1.0-game edge over the Mariners and Rangers, Toronto's playoff spot is far from secure. Kevin Gausman will take the mound for Wednesday's matchup and has been one of the AL's top starters in 2023. Toronto also has a strong bullpen with a .767 team OPS on the road. Toronto ranks 6th in strikeout rate, 6th in OBP, 10th in batting average, 12th in walk rate, 16th in runs scored, and 21st in hard-hit rate. Toronto is ranked 11th overall with a record of 83-67 and 16th in offense, scoring an average of 4.54 points per game. Toronto is ranked 5th in defense, allowing an average of 4.14 points to be scored against them per game.

1
1
MLB · Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees

Your Picks on Blue Jays vs Yankees

Picks closed
Runline
Moneyline
Total

21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Picks are opinions, not guarantees. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

New York Yankees Analysis

New York Yankees have a power ranking of 13 and are #23 for offense (scoring an average of 4.23 per game), #10 for defense (giving up an average of 4.31 points per game) and 75-74 overall. Toronto went 2-1 in their last 3 matchups against New York. New York has had difficulty getting hits which has hindered run-production. Despite a top-10 walk and home run rate, New York ranks in the bottom for batting average, on-base-percentage, and slugging percentage. Pitching has been New York's primary plan; they have the MLB's best ERA, groundball rate, and LOB%. Michael King has pitched at least 4.0 innings in his last five starts with 26 strikeouts and two walks.

Gausman Pitches Gem at Yankee Stadium, Toronto Favored in Game Two

Kevin Gausman's first start of 2023 at Yankee Stadium saw seven innings of three-hit ball with no runs. Toronto's relievers have had success in recent games, and New York's lack of offensive performance suggests that trend may continue. With the second-lowest MLB team batting average, the Yankees are 23rd in runs per game. The Blue Jays have performed well away from home, owning a .265/.335/.432 slash line, and certain batters enjoy hitting in the Bronx, such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who has a .968 OPS. Accounting for these factors, Toronto is favored in game two.

Written by Bjenkins Published on 09/19/2023 Category: MLB Picks

About the Author: Benny Jenkins is the most consistent handicapper across all sports that the industry has to offer. Consistently beating the books for the last 10 years.

SportsJawGame Predictions
Predicted score

Unavailable for this preview

Projected winnerUnavailableConfidencelow
Pick on the Spread

Published pick: Unavailable

Pick on the Total

Published pick: Unavailable

#TorontoBlueJays#NewYorkYankees

Share this preview

Facebook X Reddit Email
SportsJaw logo
Written by

SportsJaw Editorial Team

SportsJaw published this archived preview from its original game-day article. Its prediction and quoted lines are preserved as written.

About our editorial process

SportsJaw Blue Jays vs Yankees archived game preview contains historical odds and availability that may no longer be current. View history of past Blue Jays vs Yankees matchups or learn how our predictions work.

Current matchup data

Lines, trends and availability

Line movement since open

  • Moneyline · Toronto Blue Jays-116 → -115Moved
  • Moneyline · New York Yankees+106 → +103Moved
  • Spread · Toronto Blue Jays-1.5 (+150) → -1.5 (+145)Moved
  • Spread · New York Yankees+1.5 (-180) → +1.5 (-165)Moved
  • Total · Over7.5 (-110) → 7 (-110)Moved
  • Total · Under7.5 (-110) → 7 (-110)Moved

ATS and O/U trends

Toronto Blue Jays
79-63-1 matchup record · 4-6-0 ATS · 5-5-0 O/U
Last 10 completed games on file
New York Yankees
75-74 matchup record · 4-6-0 ATS · 4-6-0 O/U
Last 10 completed games on file

Injuries and availability

From the published research (2023-09-19T22:23:03.759Z). Availability may have changed; review the cited sources.

No verified injury or availability note was included in the published matchup research.

Recent head-to-head

  • 2023-09-19Toronto Blue Jays 7 · New York Yankees 1
Final result

Matchup pick recap

Toronto Blue Jays defeated New York Yankees 6-1

Toronto Blue Jays defeated New York Yankees 6-1 on September 20, 2023, a 5-run decision in the series. Toronto Blue Jays' strongest period was the 8th inning, when it outscored its opponent 2-0. Against SportsJaw's recorded Toronto Blue Jays -1.5 (+145) spread, Toronto Blue Jays covered, while the 7 total pushed.

SportsJaw editorial picks

  • Projected winnerNo published selectionUnavailable

Tipster picks

  • JeffjacksonMoneyline · New York Yankees +106Loss
  • DerekFisherTotal · Over 7.5 (-110)Loss
  • Drew_WestcottMoneyline · New York Yankees +106Loss
  • RcollinsMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -116Win
  • BjenkinsMoneyline · New York Yankees +106Loss
  • DrfeelgoodMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays +101Win
  • PremierPicksMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -118Win
  • MoneymouthTotal · Under 7.5 (-110)Win
  • NutinbutlocksMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays +101Win
  • DawhizMoneyline · New York Yankees +104Loss
  • 2738694229Moneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -121Win
  • Novacek84Moneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -120Win
  • SfdanMoneyline · New York Yankees +109Loss
  • Altuve27Total · Under 7.5 (-110)Win
  • CoolioMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -120Win
  • CoolioTotal · Over 7.5 (-110)Loss
  • OddssharkMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -120Win
  • Oddsshark
Total · Over 7.5 (-110)
Loss
  • CoversMoneyline · Toronto Blue Jays -115Win
  • Wilder83 Total · Over 7 (-110)Push